Short answer
Neither size is better in every situation. 20 mm aggregate is the usual choice for general-purpose concrete such as slabs, footings and bases, while 10 mm aggregate is often better for thin sections, tightly spaced reinforcement and work where a smooth finish matters. The right size depends mainly on how thick the pour is and how much steel is in it.
What changes with aggregate size
- Paste demand: smaller aggregate has more surface area to coat, so a 10 mm mix generally needs more cement paste and water than a 20 mm mix of similar workability. Larger aggregate can make the concrete more economical and reduce shrinkage.
- Workability: larger stones can be harder to push around in thin sections or between reinforcing bars. Smaller stone flows more easily around obstacles.
- Finish: 10 mm gives a tighter, finer surface that is easier to float and trowel. A mix with only 20 mm stone can be harder for a novice to finish smoothly, as some DIYers find.
- Strength: for the same cement content and water-cement ratio, strength is broadly similar. In practice, strength depends more on water content, compaction and curing than on aggregate size alone.
When 20 mm is the better choice
- Driveways and paths, garage floors and general ground slabs.
- Footings and foundations with generous dimensions.
- Large pours where economy matters.
Ballast sold in the UK is normally graded up to about 20 mm and includes sand, so it suits these jobs. See how much cement you need for 1 tonne of ballast.
When 10 mm is the better choice
- Thin slabs or toppings.
- Concrete around closely spaced reinforcement.
- Small precast items, steps with fine detail, planters and countertops. For the latter, see concrete countertop and worktop mix ratios.
- Repairs where the section is small (see what to patch concrete with).
Rules of thumb for maximum size
Design guides commonly suggest that the maximum aggregate size should not exceed:
- about one-fifth of the narrowest dimension of the member;
- about three-quarters of the clear spacing between reinforcing bars;
- about one-third of the depth of a slab.
A 100 mm slab, for example, comfortably takes 20 mm stone under these rules, and a 40 to 50 mm thin section does not.
Ballast and finishing
If you are mixing a slab and finding it difficult to get a neat surface, the problem may not be the aggregate. Timing is usually more important: screed, then wait for the bleed water to leave the surface before floating. Using a mix with some 10 mm stone, or adding a little more sand, can make finishing easier.
Mix adjustments
If you swap 20 mm for 10 mm in a recipe, expect to use a slightly richer mix, or more sand. Follow the proportions given for your project in our guide to concrete mix ratios, and test a small batch if you are not sure.