The short answer
Good bricklaying mortar is smooth, plastic and workable. It is often described as having a texture like peanut butter or thick porridge. It should hold its shape on the trowel, spread easily, and stick to the brick without running or slumping.
Perfect consistency varies a little with the brick (very absorbent bricks like a slightly wetter mix), the weather and your own preference, so use the tests below rather than a fixed water quantity.
Simple tests for good consistency
The trowel test. Scoop up some mortar and turn the trowel on its side or upside down. Good mortar clings to the trowel for a moment, then slides off cleanly in one piece. If it runs off or drips, it is too wet. If it sticks stubbornly or falls off in crumbs, it is probably too dry.
The furrow test. Draw the edge of the trowel through a heap of mortar. A good mix leaves a clean ridge with a smooth surface that holds its shape. Wet mortar flows back and fills the furrow. Dry mortar looks rough and torn.
The spread test. Spread a bed of mortar on a brick. It should spread evenly without tearing, and the brick should settle into it with a gentle tap.
Signs the mix is too wet
- Mortar runs or slumps off the trowel.
- Bricks sink or float and are hard to hold level.
- Mortar squeezes out heavily and drips down the face of the wall, staining the bricks.
- Joints sag and shrink while drying and may crack.
- The mortar is weaker once hardened, because extra water leaves a more porous, weaker structure, the same principle as the water-cement ratio in concrete.
Signs the mix is too dry
- The mortar is crumbly and breaks apart on the trowel.
- It is hard to spread and does not fill the bed or perpend joints.
- The bricks do not bed down well, which leaves gaps and a poor bond (see why mortar won’t stick to brick).
- It sets or stiffens too quickly and looks patchy when tooled.
How to fix it
- Too wet: add a little more of the dry mix (keeping the cement to sand ratio) and remix. If you only add sand, the ratio shifts. See mortar mix ratios for the proportions.
- Too dry: add water gradually, a small splash at a time, and mix thoroughly before testing again. It is easy to overshoot.
- Mixed in a mixer: add water last and in stages, and let the mix turn for a minute or two before judging.
Wet sand changes everything
Damp sand already contains water, so the same recipe can give a wetter mix from one day to the next. If your sand has been rained on, you will need less water. This is one of the reasons for adding water slowly. See sharp sand versus building sand for more on choosing and storing sand.
Plasticiser and workability
Plasticiser makes mortar creamier and easier to lay with less water, which is helpful for new bricklayers. Follow the product dosing. You can read more about this in our main mortar mix ratios guide.
Working time and re-tempering
Mortar starts to stiffen as it loses water to the bricks and the air, and as the cement begins to react. Mix only as much as you can use in a reasonable period, commonly within about two hours, shorter in hot or windy weather.
If mortar on the board has stiffened slightly from evaporation, it can usually be brought back by working it with the trowel and adding a little water. That is called re-tempering. Do not keep re-wetting mortar that has begun to set, because it will be weaker. Throw away batches that have clearly started to harden.
Match the consistency to the brick
- Very absorbent or dry bricks pull water out of the mortar. Dampen them lightly beforehand, and use a slightly wetter mix.
- Dense, low-absorption bricks need a stiffer mix, or the bricks will float.
- Hot or windy weather dries mortar faster. Work in smaller batches.
Getting the consistency right also helps you hold even joints; see how thick mortar joints should be.